Matt Taibbi

The statement appears to be a critique of a journalistic profile written by Thomas Chatterton Williams about Walter Kirn, published in The Atlantic. The critique labels the profile as a 'prototypical specimen in the new journalism of incomprehension,' suggesting that it exemplifies a trend in journalism that fails to truly understand its subjects. The statement also compares this trend unfavorably to another, unspecified genre, indicating it is 'only somewhat less grating.' This statement engages in public discourse as it critiques journalistic practices and implies a discussion about the quality and approach of modern journalism.

1. Principle 1:

   I will strive to do no harm with my words and actions.

   The statement does not seem to cause harm but is critical in nature, focusing on the perceived shortcomings of a journalistic style.
2. Principle 2:

   I will respect the privacy and dignity of others and will not engage in cyberbullying, harassment, or hate speech.

   The statement respects privacy and dignity, focusing on professional critique rather than personal attacks. [+1]
3. Principle 3:

   I will use my words and actions to promote understanding, empathy, and compassion.

   The statement does not actively promote understanding, empathy, or compassion. It criticizes without providing constructive insights into how journalism might improve. [-1]
4. Principle 4:

   I will engage in constructive criticism and dialogue with those in disagreement and will not engage in personal attacks or ad hominem arguments.

   The statement engages in criticism but borders on dismissiveness without engaging in a constructive dialogue or offering a solution.
5. Principle 5:

   I will acknowledge and correct my mistakes.

   There is no indication of acknowledging or correcting mistakes within the statement itself.
6. Principle 6:

   I will use my influence for the betterment of society.

   The statement uses its influence to critique but does not clearly demonstrate how it contributes to the betterment of society.
7. Principle 7:

   I will uphold the principles of free speech and use my platform responsibly and with integrity.

   The statement upholds free speech by using the platform to express opinions about journalism, though it could be argued that the integrity of the critique could be enhanced by more balanced or constructive feedback. [+1]