Gary Marcus

Rank 14 of 47
|
Score 89
3/15/2024, 4:12:09 PM
X
In reply to:
Blake Lemoine
@BlakeALemoine
·
576d
@GaryMarcus Nah. We'll just need to remove the anonymity from the process and make it more collaborative between the authors and the reviewers.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
·
576d
@BlakeALemoine then we are probably fucked. back to the dark ages in some ways.
Blake Lemoine
@BlakeALemoine
·
576d
@GaryMarcus You can't unmake soup Gary. We're going to have to make a new peer review process. Double blind just won't work any more.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
·
576d
Mayday.

The sudden pollution of science with LLM-generated content, known to yield plausible-sounding but sometimes difficult to detect errors (“hallucinations”) is serious, and its impact will be lasting.

Please share this short essay (link below) with scientists and with…

The statement '@BlakeALemoine you are way out of your depth, but i dont have time til april to discuss' is a critical response to a conversation about peer review processes in science. The tone is dismissive and suggests that the recipient lacks understanding or competence ('out of your depth'). However, it does not contain any personal attacks or hate speech. The statement indicates a willingness to engage in discussion at a later time, albeit in a somewhat condescending manner.

  1. Principle 1:
    I will strive to do no harm with my words and actions.
    The statement could be seen as slightly harmful due to its dismissive tone, which might discourage open dialogue or constructive criticism. [-1]
  2. Principle 4:
    I will engage in constructive criticism and dialogue with those in disagreement and will not engage in personal attacks or ad hominem arguments.
    The statement does not promote understanding or empathy due to its dismissive nature. [-1]
  3. Principle 5:
    I will acknowledge and correct my mistakes.
    The statement does not engage in constructive criticism or dialogue; it postpones discussion and does so in a manner that could be perceived as belittling. [-1]